Comparisons

  


Ding

    Euphronios Krater

  • Found in royal tombs

  • Mask Like faces covered the center of each side and even more down each leg (taotie)

  • Images resembling birds, dragons, magical creatures 

  • Was typical in the Shang style 

  • Usually stands on 3-4 legs

  • Purpose: cook food for rituals 

  • These rituals were often done to show power by showing connection to spirits and the supernatural

Euphronios Krater

  • Bowl used for mixing wine with water 

  • Ancient Greek terracotta

  • One of the 27 vases painted by Euphronios


Art: A Brief History by Marilyn Stokstad and Michael Cohen did a great job at including different western and non western art forms. For example, let's look at the Fang Ding, from the tomb of Lady Fu Hau in Anyang China and Euphronios Krater, one of the finest greek artifacts left. Both the Fang Ding and Euphrionos Krater are beautifully detailed vessels with their own cultural meanings and purposes. In the textbook, the authors explain the western artwork, Euphrionos Krater  in more detail in terms of the process of making the piece as compared to the non western artwork, Fang Ding. Though both the Fang Ding and Euphrionos Krater are vessels, visually and structurally they look different. The Fang Ding is in typical Shang style and usually stands on 3-4 legs while Euphrionos Krater has a rounded base that supports it. In analyzing the Fang Ding, the authors discussed how the vessel served as a purpose for rituals and holding offerings of food or wine and briefly described the piece visually. It is mentioned that features such as the face like images, birds, dragons, and other magical creatures are presented in the design of the ding. Similar to the Fang Ding, Euphrionos Krater is also a vessel for wine but in this case mixing wine and water together in the bowl. The authors elaborated on the use of red-figure and slip technique in the process of creating  Euphrionos Krater. The textbook even had “A Closer Look” page dedicated to Euphrionos Krater where the authors pinpoint the meaning of the images on the vase. Now granted, the Fang Ding although it had many images engraved on it, researchers haven’t been able to dictate the meaning behind them (the textbook states the details are still a mystery) thus, being a reason why there was limited information on the Ding. I think it would have been more effective for the authors to create “A Closer Look” for the Fang Ding as well because it makes it easier visually for the reader to see what the authors are talking about. In looking at Euphronios Krater there is no confusion in trying to look for figures such as Hyphens, Thanatos, God Hermes, and Sarpedon. As expressed, though the textbook does cover similar western and non western art pieces such as the Fang Ding and Euphrionos Krater it is limited in the way each piece is perceived by the reader. For example, Euphrionos Krater is easier to read than the Fang Ding.

A slightly different comparison we could have done would have been to compare the Fang Ding to a Guan Vare Vase as seen on page 279 of the text. I think this comparison would have shown the differences and how art evolves and what each culture did to change it’s art factors to fit its needs. The Guan Vare was a ceramic chinese piece which pours water and was intended for highly cultivated artists (Stokstad & Cothren, 217).

Comments

  1. Nice small comparison chart for a quick and easy way to understand the art works. ~Brennan Garcia

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like that you incorporated the charts we use
    -Geovanni

    ReplyDelete
  3. I enjoyed the images chosen for this comparison -Jessica Zepeda

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment