Conclusion
Art: A Brief History is a surprisingly approachable textbook for gaining an understanding of art history from a wide array of locations, eras, and styles/movements. It manages to convey many details about a given artwork, as well as the cultural and historical context surrounding it, in language that is clear and easy to read without sacrificing informational value (especially in sections focused on specific pieces and concepts such as ‘A Closer Look’). Despite this, it is not necessarily perfect. Even with multiple chapters dedicated to non-western art (which typically gets far less time and attention as western art does), the majority of the textbook’s chapters are dedicated to European/post-colonial American artwork and movements. The numerous chapters on non-western art also bear the issue of having to cover much ground in comparatively far less space. As a result, only a few regions get much attention and are largely relegated to eras long past, as more contemporary art from Europe and America has far more focus and particular regions and specific styles have more room to be discussed in comparison. This, unfortunately, limits the exposure the reader has to the arts of different cultures, as less popular/well-known regions don’t get spotlighted (for example, only India, China, and Japan, three very well known Asian countries get featured in the chapters on Asia and only African country that has an entire chapter to itself is Egypt). This results in a spotty knowledge of global art history as countless regions are relegated to obscurity. The lack of contemporary art from these non-western regions could also leave readers with the unfortunate implication that there is no worthwhile art from these regions past the eras of their famed ancient empires. A useful solution is to have more chapters focus on non-western art, in particular in regions that are less well known (even if only sections within larger chapters could help) as well as chapters dedicated to more contemporary/modern art from non-western regions. Having a single book be the comprehensive source of art from around the globe is challenging, but by being aware of the flaws that such a thing may have (even in its decent attempt so far) readers and instructors alike can work to further improve our understanding of art from around the globe.
great analysis of the positives and downfalls of the textbook
ReplyDeleteI agree about the amazing layout of the book, keeps the audience intrigued. - Mireya Arana
ReplyDeleteThat was a really good analysis on the textbook and I liked your art detective work as well
ReplyDelete