Textbook Critique
The book seems to do a fantastic job of intriguing its readers. Lots of it’s descriptions and background catch attention. Much like how on page 105, the textbook goes into detail about the beginnings of Greek Civilization before starting to elaborate on the first movement of Grecian art, Geometric Style. “[W]ith little good farmland, the Greeks turned to commerce and colonization to alleviate food shortages… Greek artists formed focused and distinctive ideals of human representation… What we call Geometric style,” (Stokstad & Cothren, 102) is a shortened version of what is actually written within the text but is still able to give a solid background of what is going on. I think visualization for the reader is important and that is something that the textbook does eloquently with the previous example. Something noticeable in the textbook is how it goes very into detail about European or West Asian art. While it is understandable that lots of both areas take the spotlight of many movements throughout history, the textbook is called Art: A Brief History not Eastern Asian and European Art: A brief History. Chapters 4-14 really show that as it emphasizes the eastern asian and european aspect. Chapter 15 which is entitled Art of the Americas only gets around 26 pages, feeling as if it only scratched the surface of the art around here (Stokstad & Cothren). They do mention and go into details about the North American Natives but for it to be jammed at the end of the chapter with the rest of the Natives from Central and South america seems a tad bit rushed. It would have been nice to see more about that specific art as it is very possible readers would have enjoyed that. The textbook does go into a slight description of the aftermath of the Spanish conquest and what it does to the art culture but it seems very fast and in a way, glossed over. That personally does not sit quite right with me as I mentioned before a large quantity of the text is attached to the other continents. Something I also noticed was that it never talked about arts relating to the Pacific Islands or Australia. I also would have enjoyed hearing about those parts considering how close they were to Japan and China and if places like the Philippines prior to Spanish Colonization had any specific art styles that were attributed or similar to Japan and China. Same with Australia, as it is known that even before Europe began to send prisoners there, it held indiginous people.
Not only are the sections on non-western arts largely focused on solely West Asian art and a smattering of African and Indigenous American artwork, the sections themselves are spread rather thin even with the limited selection. It is important that the textbook features these regions and does so spanning a wide range of time, but it is difficult to appreciate the breadth and diversity of the development of art when they are limited to only two chapters (in the case of Asian art, which again is limited to only India, China, and Japan), two chapters for art from the African continent (one solely for Egypt and one for the rest of the rest of the continent), one chapter for Indigenous American art and Middle Eastern art (which both focus largely on the past, which implicitly shows students that there aren’t any other works of art outside of those eras worth discussing). While it is understandable that their selection is limited, as a truly comprehensive art history textbook would arguably be impossible, the selection is still telling as the majority of chapters focus on European and North American art movements, in particular the work of white artists.
loved how you communicated your own opinions on the textbook (what you liked and didn't like). I also think it would have been interesting to see artworks from the Philippines and compare them to those of Japan and China.
ReplyDeletegood organization and conclusion.-janessa gomez
ReplyDelete